Elissa Gershowitz addresses the issue of trashy book and tween/teen readers in the July/August issue of “The Horn Book Magazine.” Trashy books almost always contain steamy stuff (sex or lust), controlled substances, wish-fulfillment and, of course, escapism. You usually don’t find any on a school reading list nor do most have any literary merit. Most lack staying power, but some “take on a life of their own and continue to circulate among readers over years and even decades.”
It is too early to tell, Gershowitz states, whether the “Twilight” series will continue to be popular in the years to come. It has, however, gained such popularity and spawned so many imitators that it looks like a good bet to do so.
Before there was Stephanie Meyer, there was V.C. Andrews, “the grande dame of literary trash-lit devoured by teens, who, spectacularly, put the “ick” in gothic when it comes to taboo teen sex.” In 1979, “Flowers in the Attic” was published . Four other titles were part of the Dollanganger series. These novels swept their teen readers away. In “Flowers in the Attic” beautiful Cathy is tragically removed from the outside world. Would any of the readers want to actually be Cathy or Bella? Probably not–but in the pages of these books, this kind of escapism really captured the imagination of their teen readers.
Other books in the classic “trashy” novel list are “Go Ask Alice” by Anonymous and the boy version “Jay’s Journal.” These were cautionary tales dealing with wild parties, sex, drugs, and alcohol. “Forever” by Judy Blume also makes the list. In the 1970s, this novel was deemed scandalous. Today opinion is divided. Some people see it as “pornographic trash; others (notably librarians who are forced to defend it whenever Banned Books Week roll around) view it as worthy, groundbreaking young adult fiction.”
Newer possible additions to the “trashy list” are Cecily von Ziegesar’s “Gossip Girl” books and Sara Shepard’s “Pretty Little Liars.” Just as the movies has kept the “Twilight” series popular, television has contributed to keeping Gossip Girls and Pretty Little Liars in the public eye.
Whether these contemporary “bad books” stand the test of time and take their place beside the books of Andrews, Blume, and “Anonymous” only their publishers and time will tell.